Canada’s highest court has determined that Elections Canada made a significant administrative mistake that could compromise the integrity of the electoral system by not addressing issues related to mail-in ballots in a Montreal-area constituency prior to the 2025 federal election.
In a ruling issued in February, the Supreme Court of Canada annulled the election results for the Terrebonne riding and published the rationale for its decision on Friday.
According to the court, the ruling to mandate a new election “strengthens public confidence in the electoral process by confirming that a federal election should not be determined by recognized and rectifiable official mistakes,” as stated in the decision.
In April 2025, Liberal candidate Tatiana Auguste was announced as the victor in the Montreal-area riding of Terrebonne, winning by a single vote against the incumbent Bloc Québécois candidate Nathalie Sinclair-Desgagné.
The Bloc candidate contested the election results and called for a byelection after a Bloc supporter alleged that she had attempted to vote by mail using a special ballot that was not counted.
The voter, Emmanuelle Bosse, reported that her special ballot was returned to her mailbox due to an error in the postal code printed on a label provided by Elections Canada.
A Superior Court judge denied Sinclair-Desgagné’s request for a new election, but the Supreme Court overturned that decision in a split ruling issued from the bench in February, leading to a byelection that Auguste won on April 13.
WATCH | Liberals maintain Terrebonne riding:
Liberals maintain Terrebonne riding in do-over byelection
Following a tumultuous year, Tatiana Auguste of the Liberals will represent the Quebec riding of Terrebonne in the House of Commons, having won the byelection on Monday by over 700 votes against Nathalie Sinclair-Desgagné from the Bloc Québécois.
Justice Mahmud Jamal, writing for the majority, noted that an employee of Elections Canada was aware for weeks that some voters had received envelopes with incorrect postal codes, yet the agency did not act to rectify the issue.
The decision stated, “Elections Canada did not receive or tally a voter’s ballot because it failed to take adequate steps to correct the mistake, despite being aware of its error and expecting that affected voters would be contacted by its staff.”
“Elections Canada caused the mistake and had both the capability and obligation to fix it.”
The court learned that an Elections Canada employee had mailed out incorrectly addressed envelopes for mail-in ballots to around 40 voters.
The employee recognized the error more than three weeks before the election but did not inform any supervisors, believing the mistake was not causing any issues “because the Terrebonne polling station was receiving completed special ballots in the regular course, including those in envelopes with the postal code error,” as per the decision.
WATCH | Voter reactions to Liberal victory:
Voter reactions to Liberals’ byelection win in Terrebonne, Que.
Prime Minister Mark Carney’s Liberals secured the riding outside of Montreal by approximately 700 votes in Monday’s byelection. Tatiana Auguste initially won by a single vote in April 2025, but that outcome was later voided by the Supreme Court of Canada due to an uncounted mail-in ballot.
Justice Jamal expressed that the Superior Court made a mistake in concluding that the unintentional administrative error was not significant enough to be regarded as a voting irregularity.
“Errors made unintentionally, in good faith, can also compromise the integrity of the electoral process if they obstruct voters from exercising their right to vote,” wrote the judge.
Elections Canada stated in a release that it had reviewed its special ballot procedures following the election and has already implemented changes. The agency indicated that it would thoroughly analyze the Supreme Court ruling before determining any further actions.
The agency further mentioned, “Elections Canada is continuously exploring new methods to better equip the thousands of workers involved in facilitating federal elections.”
The ruling was a split decision of 6-3.
In their dissent, Justices Andromache Karakatsanis and Sheilah Martin argued that the clerical error was not severe enough to meet the stringent criteria required to justify a re-election.
They cautioned that this decision could pave the way for additional challenges.
“If a mistake affecting a single vote is sufficient to reopen an election outcome, it is difficult to determine what type of error would not satisfy the criteria,” they commented. “Such a low standard could potentially jeopardize all election results, undermining the stability, certainty, and finality of electoral outcomes.”
Conversely, the majority maintained that the standards for overturning an election remain rigorous, asserting that the ruling will not “open the floodgates” to electoral disputes arising from every human error during an election.
Tag: rewrite-pending
Source